Family law often involves highly sensitive and emotionally charged situations, perhaps no more than in divorce cases. Among the most challenging divorce cases are those involving people with Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD), whose behaviours can significantly affect both the legal process and the wellbeing of their partner and children.
These cases are often more difficult to resolve than typical divorce proceedings. They can involve prolonged conflict, non-cooperation and increased emotional pressure.
Recognising the signs and understanding the impact of narcissism is crucial for clients and legal professionals alike.
Understanding NPD
When we talk about NPD in family law, we are referring to someone who has a diagnosable personality disorder that involves an inability to empathise, persistent patterns of grandiosity and a relentless need for admiration.
Individuals with NPD are not narcissistic by choice, but act in the way they do out of a need to avoid confronting their own deep-rooted feelings of shame and low self-esteem. They do this by creating a false persona as a shield, which needs external validation to maintain – ideally from admiration and adoration – but where the supply of that is shut off – from drama, conflict and fear.
Those affected will manipulate situations to maintain control, disregarding the feelings and needs of their partners or children. This leads to abusive relationships that become unsustainable but also makes a narcissist incredibly hard to leave because of the consequences of doing so.
Types of NPD
There are four types of NPD to look out for:
The Exhibitionist Narcissist
Grandiose, charismatic and lives for attention.
The Devaluing Narcissist
Puts people down to feel better about themselves.
The Communal Narcissist
Comes across as a do-gooder, needing to be seen by others as the most generous, most kind or the most caring.
The Closet Narcissist
The hardest type to spot – shies away from the limelight, but often associates with people who are special to feel special by association.
Common Traits of NPD
- Lack of empathy – an inability to recognise or care about others’ feelings (although they may be able to fake this to achieve their goals)
- A sense of exaggerated self-importance and entitlement
- Preoccupation with fantasies of unlimited success, power, brilliance, or beauty
- Belief that they are special and unique, and can only be understood by other high-status people
- Constant need for admiration and validation
- Tendency to exploit others for personal gain
- An inability to see others as a mixture of good and bad qualities, only all bad or all good
- Arrogant or haughty attitudes and behaviours
- Sensitivity to criticism, often reacting with rage or defensiveness
- Frequent use of manipulation tactics, such as gaslighting, belittling, or creating confusion
Prevalence
Studies indicate that Narcissistic Personality Disorder affects approximately 1% of the general population, though estimates range from 0.5% to 5%. NPD is rarely diagnosed in practice as someone with NPD does not consider that there is anything wrong them. NPD is curable in some cases, but this is rare as very few narcissists will ever seek treatment.
As a large number of the traits of NPD are those which can be desirable in a business or political context, many people with NPD are high achievers.
Impact on Divorce Proceedings
The presence of a narcissistic spouse complicates divorce cases enormously, as well as any associated children cases.
Having a narcissistic spouse significantly increases the complexity of divorce proceedings, as well as any matters involving children.
A narcissist will employ tactics such as constant blame-shifting, withholding information, and refusing to compromise. They may breach court orders or make false allegations against their spouse. They may have an overriding desire to win and to annihilate their ex-spouse, making a fair outcome difficult to reach, prolonging the process, increasing emotional distress and raising costs. They can make a spouse accept a worse outcome than they might otherwise receive due to a desire to escape the narcissist at any cost.
How the Courts Approach Narcissist Divorce Cases
Family courts do not make decisions based on personality disorder traits alone. Courts will instead focus on evidence and outcomes, particularly where children are involved.
Behaviour of parties may be relevant where it impacts:
- Child welfare and the best interests of children
- Co-parenting
- Compliance with court orders and obligations
Therefore, a structured and evidence-led approach is essential in ensuring key issues are properly recognised and addressed. The important fact here is that it’s not NPD itself that should be the focus, but how NPD manifests itself in behaviour relevant to the above, as well as in general how divorce proceedings and communication with the narcissistic party should be carried out.
6 Practical Steps When Leaving a Narcissistic Partner
When dealing with a high-conflict or controlling partner in general, regardless of the presence of NPD, taking early and proactive steps can make a significant difference, both legally and emotionally:
- Keep clear records of communications and key events
- Consider utilising a communication technique that keeps dialogue structured, limited and purposeful, such as BIFF (Brief, Informative, Friendly, Firm)
- Set clear boundaries and limitations of communication and engagement
- Avoid unnecessary engagement or disputes
- Rely on formal legal processes where appropriate
- Prioritise stability and wellbeing, particularly where children are involved
Creating a clear and proactive strategy can help minimise disruption and assist in resolution.
Protecting Clients’ Emotional Safety
For anyone leaving a narcissist, prioritising emotional safety is essential. Leaving a narcissist is incredibly difficult as their feeling of abandonment and the cutting off of narcissistic supply frequently results in lovebombing, guilt-tripping or fear-inducement to convince their spouse to stay.
It is essential that anyone planning to end a narcissistic relationship has a plan in place and appropriate emotional support from friends, family and professionals. Clear boundaries need to be set, and direct communication should be limited.
This extends into the role of lawyers. It is common to get drawn into extensive correspondence with a narcissist. This rarely helps and can exacerbate the trauma being experienced by their partner. Instead, correspondence should focus on key issues that actually make a substantive difference to the eventual outcome and drive the case forward, minimising distraction.
Seeking Legal Support
Matthew Taylor, Family Law Partner in our Liverpool office, is an expert on cases involving narcissists, and works closely with the country’s leading expert on narcissism, Dr Supriya McKenna, to provide holistic support to clients looking to escape narcissistic abuse.
Visit our family law service page for more details, or get in touch today.
Sign up for legal insights
Stay up to date with the latest alerts, training and event invitations.
